Critical Eye: Why those climate views can’t be given equal voice and hearing
The critical appraisal of a recent climate change article offers important lessons for knowledge management.
Critical Eye: Workplace Knowledge Flows
A significant proportion of knowledge management research suffers from poor experimental design. By contrast, the quasi-experimental design of research reported…
Critical Eye: ISE4GEMs – A new approach for the SDG era
A new evaluation document provides a timely reminder about what knowledge management is, and is not.
Critical Eye: Tacit knowledge paper gets lost in neuromyths, highlighting issues with evidence quality in KM
A knowledge management research paper that I recently located clearly illustrates why evidence must be critically appraised before a decision…
Critical Eye: ISO 30401 draft standard – knowledge management systems
The new standard is our best chance to establish a new, modern framework for KM, so how can we improve…
Critical Eye: Are knowledge management researchers really more unethical, or is there more to the story?
An award-winning paper states that "knowledge management has the highest number of retracted articles with plagiarism as the predominant ethical…
Critical Eye: Evidence of the importance of curation
Knowledge management as a discipline has a mixed track record in seeking out high-quality evidence for its tools, techniques and…
Critical Eye: Bird Island experiment claims to prove usefulness of KM
Knoco's 2009 Bird Island case study demonstrates improved performance but falls short in showing that the net results of KM…
Critical Eye: An example of hype in science publishing and reporting
A paper published in a respected journal illustrates the hyping of language used in science and the low quality of…